Part 1
Part one of this assignment I did
at Universal Studios with my family. I was not a loud to talk at least with
using words or using different forms of language. Even though it was kind of
difficult, it was not impossible. They kept trying to ask my deep questions
that were a little more than a nod of the head or just a simple laugh. They were
actually quite impossible to answer so I just glared at them instead. They did
keep trying to ask me questions and different forms of questions to try and get
me to crack.
I was in a small group of people
however it was one person that kept talking to me and trying to crack me and
yes, he definitely controlled the conversation, he was the one changing the
topics, and he asked all of the questions while I ‘tried’ to answer. I was not
really excluded too much also, it was almost like I got more attention since they
felt the need to crack me. My partner definitely had the power for this fifteen
minutes. Like I said he lead all the questions and conversations with me. I almost
felt powerless since some things I couldn’t even respond to and I could not
talk or contribute anything to the conversation. I had no power in this
conversation therefore it was not balanced.
I Believe
that the spoken language would have the advantage here with communicating complex
ideas within their population because I could not even imagine a lot of people
just making a bunch of faces at each other and waving their arms and getting
anything done! I think the spoken language people would just be very easily irritated
at the people that only use gestures thinking, “just speak up”. I would also
think that they would think that they are not as mature, almost like a baby who
does not know how to talk.
Part 2
Part
two of this assignment was also doe at universal Studios with my family. This one
I was aloud to talk but not use any gestures, hands, smiles, or smirks. This
one was definitely harder than part one. I feel like part one there are clear
easy guidelines… just don’t talk. Where this one was a little more vague it was
way harder to tell when you would make a facial gesture or accidentally use
your hands. The hardest part for me though was smiling. If you are saying no body
language, then that means you really can’t laugh when something is funny (which
of course, everything became funny right as soon as I started) because that is
almost an expression of how you are feeling, and you couldn’t give a nice warm
smile to someone as they walked by. I almost felt mean with this part just
because I felt like I could not smile or laugh I just had to be monotoned and
boring. I do not think they were really affected too much by my lack of body
language. Once again, they were trying to crack me and point out every little
thing that was funny or they would tell a joke… this is where they got me I did
crack quite a few times doing this part.
I think
yes, signs are useful, but they are not as useful as the language itself. I think
being able to talk is more useful and productive but, it is very, very hard to
speak with out doing some kind of signs or body language. I think speaking with
no emotions is kind of like having conversations over text. They could be a
great way for communication and just talking and keeping friends, but then
again it could also go very wrong by the way they perceive you.
A smile
goes a long way and sometimes actions do speak louder than words. Like I have
said previously speaking is more useful and can get more things done, or even
get them started but it is very hard to go around in your every day life
without using any body language. That is just one thing that I feel like comes
so naturally and you don’t even have to think about it. I think body language
is also so much more than what we think. It reveals your personality are you
timid and shy? It will show. Are you a bit obnoxious? I’m sure that will also
show in the way you conduct yourself. This will help you though life. Kind of
how you need confidence in that interview to maybe get that job or sometimes
you have to fake it. People supposedly love confidence and I feel like a lot of
that is shown in your body language.
I’m not
sure if there is anyone who has a hard time reading body language, none come to
mind. Maybe animals or babies. I think it is not as helpful to just judge
someone off of an interview, like I was saying before. People fake it to make
it all the time. That may not be there actual selves. Also, movies, those are
all actors. You cannot expect those people you see in movies to conduct
themselves the same exact way off of the movie as you would on the movie.
Good opening description of your part A experiment. Quite entertaining! Good discussion as well on the issue of power and control in the discussion.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your conclusion regarding which culture has the advantage and the attitude of the speaking to the non-speaking culture.
Missing the final point in that section? Can you think of a real-life situation that mirrors the conditions of this experiment, namely one in which there is a power imbalance in the conversation?
Part B:
While you did a good job of describing your second experiment, I suspect that the conditions in which you conducted this detracted from the results. If those you are talking to are distracted and not paying attention to how you are communicating, they may not feel the impact of your lack of body language. It definitely colors your conclusions in the next section.
"... they are not as useful as the language itself."
Yeah, that's not the conclusion you should have drawn from this. Your results are your results, but body language and spoken language are both necessary for full communication They are two sides to the same coin. Students conducting this part of the experiment often find their partners becoming extremely uncomfortable, with some even getting angry and walking out. I'm afraid you missed out on gaining insights into the importance of body language as a result of the distracting environment in which you ran this experiment.
"I think speaking with no emotions is kind of like having conversations over text."
Yes, but we've even figured out how to include body language in our texts, haven't we? When we include emojis, we are applying body language to text to help avoid miscommunication. Emojis are further evidence of just how important body language is to communication.
With regard to the adaptive benefit, body language goes far beyond helping us negotiate our way through life. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce. Think also about how it would negatively impact our survival if we couldn't figure out who we could trust.
There are groups of people who have great difficulty or an outright inability to read body language due to physical or mental disability, such as those who are in the autism spectrum or those who are blind (though they can read vocal intonation).
I'm not sure I understand what movies in actors have to do with this?
Missing the final point on when it might be better to avoid reading body language. Is there any situation you can think of where body language might actually mislead you, not because the person is lying but because you don't know how to read the body language? Do all cultures use the same system of body language? They all use different systems of spoken/written language, so why would we assume their body language isn't different? If you travel to another country, can you trust the information you get from their body language?